This verse highlights the importance of protecting family honor and the sacredness of covenant practices.
In this passage, the sons of Jacob present a conditional requirement to the men of Shechem following the violation of their sister, Dinah, by Shechem the prince, son of Hamor. They state, “But if you will not listen to us to be circumcised, then we will take our daughter and go.” (v.17) This ultimatum reflects a demand for a commitment that goes beyond mere words. The requirement of circumcision was not just a physical act but symbolized participation in the covenant people of Israel, a significant and sacred ritual originally commanded to Abraham (Genesis 17:10). Here, the sons of Jacob essentially demand that Shechem’s household adopt their distinctive sign of covenant obedience, or lose the opportunity to intermarry. The mention of “our daughter” ties Dinah to the broader family of Jacob and underscores the protective stance the family is taking on her behalf.
Geographically, this scene unfolds in the region of Shechem, an ancient city located in the hill country of Ephraim, approximately forty miles north of Jerusalem in what would later become the central part of biblical Israel. Historically, Shechem had been significant since the days Abraham first entered Canaan, around 2091 BC to 2080 BC, as recorded in Genesis 12:6. By the time of Jacob, who likely lived between approximately 2006 BC and 1859 BC, the land was populated by Canaanite tribes—of which Hamor and his son Shechem were influential local leaders. Their internal standing in the city gave them the authority to negotiate with Jacob’s sons on behalf of their people and to implement far-reaching decisions like mass circumcision.
The verse reveals the seriousness with which Jacob’s sons approach the moral transgression. Their stipulation for circumcision stands as a boundary that, if not accepted, would conclude any possibility of alliance between the families. They recognize that if the men of Shechem do not abide by their terms, they will not hesitate to remove Dinah from that environment. (v.17)
Set to dark mode
Genesis 34:17 meaning
In this passage, the sons of Jacob present a conditional requirement to the men of Shechem following the violation of their sister, Dinah, by Shechem the prince, son of Hamor. They state, “But if you will not listen to us to be circumcised, then we will take our daughter and go.” (v.17) This ultimatum reflects a demand for a commitment that goes beyond mere words. The requirement of circumcision was not just a physical act but symbolized participation in the covenant people of Israel, a significant and sacred ritual originally commanded to Abraham (Genesis 17:10). Here, the sons of Jacob essentially demand that Shechem’s household adopt their distinctive sign of covenant obedience, or lose the opportunity to intermarry. The mention of “our daughter” ties Dinah to the broader family of Jacob and underscores the protective stance the family is taking on her behalf.
Geographically, this scene unfolds in the region of Shechem, an ancient city located in the hill country of Ephraim, approximately forty miles north of Jerusalem in what would later become the central part of biblical Israel. Historically, Shechem had been significant since the days Abraham first entered Canaan, around 2091 BC to 2080 BC, as recorded in Genesis 12:6. By the time of Jacob, who likely lived between approximately 2006 BC and 1859 BC, the land was populated by Canaanite tribes—of which Hamor and his son Shechem were influential local leaders. Their internal standing in the city gave them the authority to negotiate with Jacob’s sons on behalf of their people and to implement far-reaching decisions like mass circumcision.
The verse reveals the seriousness with which Jacob’s sons approach the moral transgression. Their stipulation for circumcision stands as a boundary that, if not accepted, would conclude any possibility of alliance between the families. They recognize that if the men of Shechem do not abide by their terms, they will not hesitate to remove Dinah from that environment. (v.17)