They reacted to the crisis by outwardly mourning and then choosing to return for resolution.
As a sudden and dramatic response to the discovery of Joseph’s silver cup in Benjamin’s sack, “Then they tore their clothes, and when each man loaded his donkey, they returned to the city” (Genesis 44:13). Tearing one’s garments was a recognized practice in ancient Near Eastern cultures, signifying extreme grief or distress (2 Samuel 1:11). By ripping their clothes, these brothers are showing deep regret and alarm over this dire situation. They had sworn earlier to protect Benjamin at all costs (Genesis 43:9), so the discovery of the cup in his possession would have felt devastating, as if everything they had pledged was now in jeopardy.
“Then they tore their clothes, and when each man loaded his donkey, they returned to the city” (v.13) also conveys that the brothers did not attempt to run away or abandon Benjamin. They could have chosen to flee the scene, but instead, they turned back toward Joseph’s Egyptian headquarters to face the consequences. Egypt at this time was a powerful kingdom in the ancient world, often traced back over two thousand years before Christ. Joseph himself is believed to have lived during the early second millennium BC, around 1914 - 1805 BC. His service under Pharaoh places him in a significant position of authority, making the brothers’ situation all the more perilous upon their return.
Finally, these words, “they returned to the city” (v.13), highlight the spiritual journey that is unfolding. Going back to Joseph next sets up a moment where hidden sins would be revealed and tested. This foreshadows the New Testament theme that God often brings trials into our path not to destroy us but to lead us toward repentance and redemption (Romans 2:4). In the same way the brothers were confronted, so too believers are challenged to face the truth with humility.
Set to dark mode
Genesis 44:13 meaning
As a sudden and dramatic response to the discovery of Joseph’s silver cup in Benjamin’s sack, “Then they tore their clothes, and when each man loaded his donkey, they returned to the city” (Genesis 44:13). Tearing one’s garments was a recognized practice in ancient Near Eastern cultures, signifying extreme grief or distress (2 Samuel 1:11). By ripping their clothes, these brothers are showing deep regret and alarm over this dire situation. They had sworn earlier to protect Benjamin at all costs (Genesis 43:9), so the discovery of the cup in his possession would have felt devastating, as if everything they had pledged was now in jeopardy.
“Then they tore their clothes, and when each man loaded his donkey, they returned to the city” (v.13) also conveys that the brothers did not attempt to run away or abandon Benjamin. They could have chosen to flee the scene, but instead, they turned back toward Joseph’s Egyptian headquarters to face the consequences. Egypt at this time was a powerful kingdom in the ancient world, often traced back over two thousand years before Christ. Joseph himself is believed to have lived during the early second millennium BC, around 1914 - 1805 BC. His service under Pharaoh places him in a significant position of authority, making the brothers’ situation all the more perilous upon their return.
Finally, these words, “they returned to the city” (v.13), highlight the spiritual journey that is unfolding. Going back to Joseph next sets up a moment where hidden sins would be revealed and tested. This foreshadows the New Testament theme that God often brings trials into our path not to destroy us but to lead us toward repentance and redemption (Romans 2:4). In the same way the brothers were confronted, so too believers are challenged to face the truth with humility.