Joseph tests his brothers' loyalty by threatening to enslave Benjamin, revealing the family’s growth toward unity and genuine repentance.
Joseph, who at this point in the narrative holds a position of power in Egypt (likely around 1880-1800 BC), addresses his brothers regarding the discovery of his special silver cup in Benjamin’s sack. He emphatically states, “Far be it from me to do this. The man in whose possession the cup has been found, he shall be my slave, but as for you, go up in peace to your father” (v.17). Joseph’s words are intended to test his brothers’ loyalty and reveal their hearts, for he threatens to keep Benjamin as a slave while allowing the others to return home. In this moment, Joseph is evaluating whether his brothers have changed from the days when they sold him into slavery (Genesis 37:28).
The emotion of this verse lies in the tension Joseph creates by offering freedom to all except Benjamin. On the surface, Joseph seems to be harsh, but this stern approach is a way to determine whether his family has truly repented of past misdeeds. By binding the youngest, the favored son of Jacob, Joseph puts them in the same position they were in decades earlier when they betrayed him. This test also highlights the responsibility and unity that the brothers are now ready to demonstrate, revealing that they value their father’s peace and Benjamin’s well-being over their own self-preservation.
In the broader narrative of Genesis, this moment foreshadows Joseph’s eventual revelation of his identity and the reconciliation of Jacob’s family. By instructing them to go in peace without Benjamin, “but as for you, go up in peace to your father” (v.17), Joseph intentionally evokes their memory of guilt. In time, they will voluntarily offer themselves to spare the youngest brother, contrasting their original betrayal. This development points to a spiritual truth woven throughout Scripture, where God allows testing to bring about insight, courage, and eventual redemption (Romans 8:28).
Set to dark mode
Genesis 44:17 meaning
Joseph, who at this point in the narrative holds a position of power in Egypt (likely around 1880-1800 BC), addresses his brothers regarding the discovery of his special silver cup in Benjamin’s sack. He emphatically states, “Far be it from me to do this. The man in whose possession the cup has been found, he shall be my slave, but as for you, go up in peace to your father” (v.17). Joseph’s words are intended to test his brothers’ loyalty and reveal their hearts, for he threatens to keep Benjamin as a slave while allowing the others to return home. In this moment, Joseph is evaluating whether his brothers have changed from the days when they sold him into slavery (Genesis 37:28).
The emotion of this verse lies in the tension Joseph creates by offering freedom to all except Benjamin. On the surface, Joseph seems to be harsh, but this stern approach is a way to determine whether his family has truly repented of past misdeeds. By binding the youngest, the favored son of Jacob, Joseph puts them in the same position they were in decades earlier when they betrayed him. This test also highlights the responsibility and unity that the brothers are now ready to demonstrate, revealing that they value their father’s peace and Benjamin’s well-being over their own self-preservation.
In the broader narrative of Genesis, this moment foreshadows Joseph’s eventual revelation of his identity and the reconciliation of Jacob’s family. By instructing them to go in peace without Benjamin, “but as for you, go up in peace to your father” (v.17), Joseph intentionally evokes their memory of guilt. In time, they will voluntarily offer themselves to spare the youngest brother, contrasting their original betrayal. This development points to a spiritual truth woven throughout Scripture, where God allows testing to bring about insight, courage, and eventual redemption (Romans 8:28).