They were accused of a grave offense, but it was actually part of Joseph's loving plan.
“Is not this the one from which my lord drinks and which he indeed uses for divination? You have done wrong in doing this.” (v.5)
Here, Joseph’s steward confronts the terrified sons of Jacob after they have departed from Egypt, accusing them of stealing Joseph’s prized silver cup. At this point in history, around 1900 B.C., Joseph has risen from slavery to become second-in-command over the land of Egypt, a kingdom located in the northeast corner of Africa, nourished by the life-giving waters of the Nile River. Placed strategically in their sack as part of Joseph’s plan, the silver cup was presented as an emblem of his supposed ability to divine hidden truths. Although Genesis 44:5 indicates “divination,” Joseph seems to be using the Egyptian custom as a tool in his larger test of heart and repentance for his brothers.
Calling it “the one from which my lord drinks and which he indeed uses for divination” (v.5) underscores the cup’s importance and highlights the solemn nature of the accusation. Joseph, who entered Egypt after his jealous brothers sold him into slavery, knew well how to engineer a moment that would reveal his brothers’ true character. His life itself foreshadows the suffering of the Messiah—Joseph was rejected, wrongly punished, and later exalted, similar to how Jesus would be rejected then glorified centuries later. Many passages emphasize that Joseph is a type of Christ, echoing spiritual truths of betrayal and ultimate restoration.
By orchestrating this dramatic scenario involving his prized cup, Joseph tests whether his older siblings have changed from when they heartlessly sold him long ago. This moment forms the climax of a series of trials that force them to face guilt, confess their wrongdoing, and demonstrate loyalty to one another. The cup thus symbolizes revelation: uncovering past misdeeds and paving the way for repentance, forgiveness, and ultimately, reconciliation. In the New Testament, Jesus—who never needed any instrument to attain divine insight—offers forgiveness to those weighed down by guilt, akin to how Joseph offered mercy to his repentant brothers (Luke 23:34).
Set to dark mode
Genesis 44:5 meaning
“Is not this the one from which my lord drinks and which he indeed uses for divination? You have done wrong in doing this.” (v.5)
Here, Joseph’s steward confronts the terrified sons of Jacob after they have departed from Egypt, accusing them of stealing Joseph’s prized silver cup. At this point in history, around 1900 B.C., Joseph has risen from slavery to become second-in-command over the land of Egypt, a kingdom located in the northeast corner of Africa, nourished by the life-giving waters of the Nile River. Placed strategically in their sack as part of Joseph’s plan, the silver cup was presented as an emblem of his supposed ability to divine hidden truths. Although Genesis 44:5 indicates “divination,” Joseph seems to be using the Egyptian custom as a tool in his larger test of heart and repentance for his brothers.
Calling it “the one from which my lord drinks and which he indeed uses for divination” (v.5) underscores the cup’s importance and highlights the solemn nature of the accusation. Joseph, who entered Egypt after his jealous brothers sold him into slavery, knew well how to engineer a moment that would reveal his brothers’ true character. His life itself foreshadows the suffering of the Messiah—Joseph was rejected, wrongly punished, and later exalted, similar to how Jesus would be rejected then glorified centuries later. Many passages emphasize that Joseph is a type of Christ, echoing spiritual truths of betrayal and ultimate restoration.
By orchestrating this dramatic scenario involving his prized cup, Joseph tests whether his older siblings have changed from when they heartlessly sold him long ago. This moment forms the climax of a series of trials that force them to face guilt, confess their wrongdoing, and demonstrate loyalty to one another. The cup thus symbolizes revelation: uncovering past misdeeds and paving the way for repentance, forgiveness, and ultimately, reconciliation. In the New Testament, Jesus—who never needed any instrument to attain divine insight—offers forgiveness to those weighed down by guilt, akin to how Joseph offered mercy to his repentant brothers (Luke 23:34).