All other sources of spiritual guidance deceive, but trusting in God’s wisdom leads to truth.
“When they say to you, ‘Consult the mediums and the spiritists who whisper and mutter,’ should not a people consult their God? Should they consult the dead on behalf of the living?” (v.19). In this verse, the prophet Isaiah—who ministered in the southern kingdom of Judah around 740-681 BC—addresses the people’s temptation to seek supernatural guidance from sources other than the LORD. During Isaiah’s time, Judah was often influenced by the religious practices of neighboring nations, and mediums or spiritists promised hidden insight into life’s mysteries. Isaiah’s rhetorical question, “Should they consult the dead on behalf of the living?” (v.19), underscores how the living God far surpasses any alternative spiritual avenues. His rebuke indicates that God’s covenant people needed to remember who truly possesses power and authority over all creation.
“When they say to you, ‘Consult the mediums and the spiritists who whisper and mutter…’” (v.19) highlights an appeal some Israelites were making to human traditions and forbidden occult practices. Instead of turning to a personal, loving God for guidance, they were drifting toward pagan customs. In the broader context of Isaiah’s prophecies, the prophet consistently reminds the people of Judah that they must rely on God alone. Elsewhere in Scripture, the importance of seeking divine wisdom is echoed in places such as James 1:5, where believers are encouraged to ask God for wisdom rather than relying on human or demonic counsel.
The question, “Should not a people consult their God?” (v.19), expresses God’s desire for an exclusive relationship with His people, one that ultimately foreshadows the coming of a Messiah who would offer a direct way to commune with God (John 14:6). By admonishing the people to reject spiritists, Isaiah draws a firm boundary: the Lord is the sole, legitimate source of true revelation. In this light, Isaiah’s prophecy calls everyone, then and now, to discern the spiritual counsel they seek and to remember that the living God reigns supreme over life and death.
Set to dark mode
Isaiah 8:19 meaning
“When they say to you, ‘Consult the mediums and the spiritists who whisper and mutter,’ should not a people consult their God? Should they consult the dead on behalf of the living?” (v.19). In this verse, the prophet Isaiah—who ministered in the southern kingdom of Judah around 740-681 BC—addresses the people’s temptation to seek supernatural guidance from sources other than the LORD. During Isaiah’s time, Judah was often influenced by the religious practices of neighboring nations, and mediums or spiritists promised hidden insight into life’s mysteries. Isaiah’s rhetorical question, “Should they consult the dead on behalf of the living?” (v.19), underscores how the living God far surpasses any alternative spiritual avenues. His rebuke indicates that God’s covenant people needed to remember who truly possesses power and authority over all creation.
“When they say to you, ‘Consult the mediums and the spiritists who whisper and mutter…’” (v.19) highlights an appeal some Israelites were making to human traditions and forbidden occult practices. Instead of turning to a personal, loving God for guidance, they were drifting toward pagan customs. In the broader context of Isaiah’s prophecies, the prophet consistently reminds the people of Judah that they must rely on God alone. Elsewhere in Scripture, the importance of seeking divine wisdom is echoed in places such as James 1:5, where believers are encouraged to ask God for wisdom rather than relying on human or demonic counsel.
The question, “Should not a people consult their God?” (v.19), expresses God’s desire for an exclusive relationship with His people, one that ultimately foreshadows the coming of a Messiah who would offer a direct way to commune with God (John 14:6). By admonishing the people to reject spiritists, Isaiah draws a firm boundary: the Lord is the sole, legitimate source of true revelation. In this light, Isaiah’s prophecy calls everyone, then and now, to discern the spiritual counsel they seek and to remember that the living God reigns supreme over life and death.