They question Moses’ leadership because they fear dying of thirst, revealing their struggle to believe that God will provide.
As Moses led the Israelites through the arid terrain near Kadesh in the wilderness of Zin, the people struggled with thirst and fear. In their frustration, they demanded of Moses, asking, “Why then have you brought the LORD’s assembly into this wilderness, for us and our beasts to die here?” (v.4). The surrounding area was both treacherous and barren, often referred to as a region “great and terrible” because of its scorching heat and scarcity of life-sustaining resources, echoing the harsh conditions described elsewhere in the Pentateuch. Though the exodus from Egypt was meant to lead God’s people into a land of blessing, the question in this verse highlights their doubt and weariness in the face of hardship.
Historically, this setting took place sometime around the late stages of Israel’s wilderness journey, possibly near the end of Moses’ life (circa mid-1400s BC). Moses, who was from the tribe of Levi, had already witnessed multiple rebellions and complaints from his fellow Israelites, but the complaint here again pointed to the people’s faltering trust and failure to remember past deliverances. The wilderness of Zin, according to other biblical references, would be the area in which Moses disobeyed God by striking the rock rather than speaking to it, an act that prevented him from entering the Promised Land. This verse crystallizes a pivotal moment of tension—Israel standing between faith in God’s provision and fear of their present circumstances.
This verse portrays the Israelites’ desperation and underscores the critical choice facing God’s people: trust the LORD or succumb to panic in the desert’s testing ground.
Set to dark mode
Numbers 20:4 meaning
As Moses led the Israelites through the arid terrain near Kadesh in the wilderness of Zin, the people struggled with thirst and fear. In their frustration, they demanded of Moses, asking, “Why then have you brought the LORD’s assembly into this wilderness, for us and our beasts to die here?” (v.4). The surrounding area was both treacherous and barren, often referred to as a region “great and terrible” because of its scorching heat and scarcity of life-sustaining resources, echoing the harsh conditions described elsewhere in the Pentateuch. Though the exodus from Egypt was meant to lead God’s people into a land of blessing, the question in this verse highlights their doubt and weariness in the face of hardship.
Historically, this setting took place sometime around the late stages of Israel’s wilderness journey, possibly near the end of Moses’ life (circa mid-1400s BC). Moses, who was from the tribe of Levi, had already witnessed multiple rebellions and complaints from his fellow Israelites, but the complaint here again pointed to the people’s faltering trust and failure to remember past deliverances. The wilderness of Zin, according to other biblical references, would be the area in which Moses disobeyed God by striking the rock rather than speaking to it, an act that prevented him from entering the Promised Land. This verse crystallizes a pivotal moment of tension—Israel standing between faith in God’s provision and fear of their present circumstances.
This verse portrays the Israelites’ desperation and underscores the critical choice facing God’s people: trust the LORD or succumb to panic in the desert’s testing ground.